Market Watch 86: Having an alert is not the same as having an effective control
Updated: Oct 16

By Simon Appleton, Market Abuse & Surveillance Director, MAR360
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has published Market Watch 86, setting out its findings from supervisory visits to seven UK retail brokers and the systems, controls and governance they use to identify and report market abuse. Ten years after the Market Abuse Regulation came into force in 2016, the FCA says these arrangements should be well established. Yet it found material weaknesses, required all seven firms to strengthen their surveillance and, in some cases, used skilled person reviews to obtain assurance over remediation.
The FCA grouped its findings into four areas. On alert investigation, several firms set the bar for reasonable suspicion too high. Some procedures told analysts not to escalate unless they could find a clear link between the client and the issuer, and others steered analysts towards reasons to close alerts. On surveillance systems and calibration, some firms applied a single price-move threshold to large and small cap stocks alike, set minimum notional values so high that a significant share of client trading went unmonitored, relied on vendors' out-of-the-box settings, and tested their calibration only superficially. On governance, some senior managers had limited understanding of key surveillance activities, and quality assurance (QA) ranged from comprehensive to non-existent.
The fourth area, and the focus of this article, is the market abuse risk assessment (MARA). It is not the first time the regulator has raised the point. Market Watch 69 in 2022 and Market Watch 73 in 2023 both highlighted weaknesses in how firms assess their market abuse risks and align surveillance to them.
In this latest review, the FCA found that some firms had not considered all relevant aspects of their business model, such as their client base and the instruments they trade. Some had not distinguished between institutional and retail clients, meaning the assessment did not reflect the firm's actual client base.
From alert coverage to control effectiveness
The FCA also observed that some firms had mistakenly assumed that having an alert in place was evidence of an effective control, capable of mitigating risk.
What the regulator expects is a risk assessment that is granular enough to reflect the firm's clients and the instruments it trades, and which is used to identify gaps in surveillance coverage and control effectiveness, and to set remediation priorities. Control effectiveness should be demonstrated through evidence such as QA findings, STOR submissions, and alert and calibration reviews.
A mapping of risks to alerts may appear complete on paper. It does not show whether thresholds are appropriate for the firm's trading activity, or whether the alerts are producing meaningful outcomes. The FCA's calibration findings illustrate the point. An insider dealing alert with a flat price-move threshold, or a minimum notional value set too high, still appears on the risk map as a control, while leaving a significant share of client activity unmonitored.
What strikes me is that, ten years after MAR came into force, the FCA is still finding firms that confuse having an alert with having a control. An alert is only a control if it is calibrated effectively, the people running it can explain how it works, and it has been tested to show it fires when it should. Out-of-the-box vendor settings that nobody has challenged are not a control. They are an assumption.
Firms should also take note that a STOR requires reasonable suspicion, not proof. Procedures that require analysts to find a link between a client and the issuer before escalating clearly set the bar too high.
Relevance beyond retail brokers
Although the review focused on retail brokers, the FCA states that its findings may also be relevant to other types of firm. Asset managers and equity brokers should consider the findings in the context of their own business.
For buy-side firms, the equivalent questions are whether the MARA distinguishes between strategies, funds and mandates with different risk profiles, whether it reflects exposure to less liquid instruments, and whether it has been updated to reflect changes such as new asset classes, brokers or trading venues.
In my view, a MARA that is reviewed once a year, separately from the surveillance it is meant to inform, is unlikely to meet these expectations. Firms that have conducted and acted upon a comprehensive and up-to-date market abuse risk assessment should already be able to evidence the link between their risks, their controls and the outcomes those controls produce. The potential for regulatory scrutiny is higher for firms that cannot.
Moving beyond the spreadsheet MARA
When we designed MARA at MAR360, our starting point was that a market abuse risk assessment should not be a spreadsheet revisited once a year. We built it to be automated and connected to trade and communications surveillance, so that risks, controls and the evidence of their effectiveness sit in one place and stay current as the business changes.
Over the past two years we have discussed this approach with many firms. Some shared that vision early and adopted MARA. Many others were comfortable with their existing spreadsheet-based assessment and did not yet see the value in changing.
That was an understandable position. A spreadsheet is familiar, and for a long time it was widely regarded as sufficient. Market Watch 86 suggests that view is becoming harder to sustain. The expectations the FCA has now set out - a granular assessment that reflects the firm's business, is used to identify gaps and prioritise remediation, and is supported by evidence that controls are effective - closely reflect the principles MARA was built on.
For firms still relying on a static assessment, this is a good moment to ask whether it can meet those expectations.
The same thinking applies to the FCA's other findings. Alongside MARA, MAR360 provides ex-regulator-led calibration and back-testing of surveillance alerts, and scenario-based, role-specific training through MAR360 Academy for the analysts who review alerts and the senior managers who oversee them.
Additional Resources:
Read Market Watch 86 in full on the FCA's website – the link is in the first comment below.https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/newsletters/market-watch-86
To learn more about how MAR360's MARA could help your firm align its market abuse risk assessment with its trade and communications surveillance, or to book a free 45-minute MARA Health Check, please get in touch at www.mar360.com or by emailing info@mar360.com.


Comments